People gathered around a table making holiday gifts with decorations and a Christmas tree in the background.
Shoppers Report This DIY Holiday Shortcut Actually Pays Off
Written by Edwin Potter on 5/14/2025

You know what’s really wrecking my December? Not the frozen driveway (though, yeah, that sucks), but this endless spiral of overspending when my wallet’s already gasping for air. Apparently, shoppers are ready to blow even more cash this year—just look at the 2024 holiday shopping report. Meanwhile, my neighbor’s out here gloating about her “life-saving” DIY gift baskets. I used to roll my eyes, but maybe she’s onto something? Turns out, hacking holiday costs with these DIY gift kits, the ones you cobble together yourself, ends up being way more effective than chasing every last coupon. I swear I saw a stat somewhere (maybe Real Simple? Or was it Good Housekeeping? I lose track) that said nearly 60% of people got handmade gifts last year and—wait for it—they actually valued them more than Amazon stuff. Wild.

Honestly, I have to laugh. First time I tried those Pinterest-y hot cocoa jars, I gave up halfway and panic-bought socks. Yet, my coworkers still talk about those lopsided, glitter-bombed jars like they were legendary. I’m not alone—there’s this list of ways people save and, yeah, DIY hacks are everywhere. Is it the bulk marshmallows? The fact that I don’t have to hunt down a million discount codes? No clue. Even retail analysts (actual humans, not bots) admit these creative shortcuts win out both in terms of spending and, weirdly, sentimentality. My homemade cards with crooked sequins? Apparently, those are a hit. Go figure.

So now I’m just sitting here, confused. Is the real shortcut the endless digital deal chase (you know, those “hack your holiday” posts that pop up every five seconds), or is it this urge to glue and bake and jar everything in sight? My cousin’s obsessed with her hand-pressed cookie recipe. I’m eyeing the clearance headphones. But every retail survey says homemade stuff is what people remember. If only I could remember who’s gluten-free. Or allergic to walnuts. Or both.

Why People Keep Coming Back to DIY Holiday Shortcuts

Shoppers happily creating DIY holiday gifts and decorations in a festive store filled with holiday supplies and decorations.

Did I ever think duct tape would outsmart the shipping cutoff panic? Nope. But then my friend whipped out a roll and strung up last-minute garlands that actually stayed put. Now my social feeds are flooded with DIY shortcuts. Everyone’s promising “holiday wins” if you just skip the overpriced premade kits and the shipping roulette.

Holiday Shopping Habits: Seriously, Who Knows?

Trying to predict when people start shopping? Don’t even bother. There’s data everywhere—67% of folks want to be done by November, but 21% wait for December, and a tiny 10% get the jump in October. Less than 1% are true last-minute maniacs.

Last year, I ditched the $12 gift wrap and went rogue with brown paper, stamps, and a ball of twine. My aunt thought I’d blown the budget at some fancy shop. People are tired—shipping’s expensive, bows fall off, ornaments break, and honestly, buying is not always the shortcut. It’s not nostalgia, it’s just survival mode. If you want a shortcut, you make one up.

Chasing “Best Holiday Deals” (And Failing)

Let’s just say it: “Holiday sale” banners mean nothing to me after that glow-in-the-dark sweater disaster. I get more satisfaction from weird, cheap ways to make gifts look good—especially since the real deal-hunters are already on the hunt for discounts before Halloween is even over. By late October, half the country’s done shopping.

Everyone acts like Black Friday is the holy grail, but it’s mostly for TVs, not teacher gifts. I hoard coupons, use every loyalty app, and save jars for homemade mixes. Oatmeal parfaits? Teachers love them. There’s this odd thrill in piecing together something cool from clearance leftovers. Not glamorous. But my bank account’s happier for it.

Millennials: Lazy or Just Done With Candle Gift Sets?

Millennials catch a lot of heat (avocado toast, blah blah), but my cousins have their carts full before Halloween. I saw this trend breakdown saying we want convenience and gifts that actually matter (sorry, generic candles).

Scroll through #GiftHacks and you’ll see the best deals come from not buying at all—drive-thru light shows, DIY baskets, whatever. Supposedly 29% of shopping is done by late October—no wonder Target’s shelves look raided. Nobody wants to pay for shipping. And those “shop with me” YouTubers? They’re not just selling stuff, they’re gaming the system, squeezing sales and hacks into every spare minute—while, somehow, never actually finishing their wrapping.

How This DIY Shortcut Actually Plays Out

A person wrapping a holiday gift at home with festive decorations and a smartphone nearby showing a shopping list.

So, I made this shortcut work—don’t ask me how, but it’s easier than assembling IKEA furniture (I’m still missing that wrench). You end up with real gifts, sometimes cash back, and if you set up affiliate stuff right, you can even snag a commission. My aunt keeps asking if it’s sketchy. It’s not. You just need a little hustle and a lot of patience.

Getting Started (Prepare for Annoyance)

Here’s where I messed up: everyone says, “Just use the app!” but nobody warns you about the login pop-ups that never remember your info, no matter how many times you save the password. I pick my favorite store (the one that actually remembers my wishlist). Most people in the forums say you have to go through the partner referral page—otherwise, the cash-back never tracks.

You have to click every single link or code. Miss one and, poof, no rewards. Some poor guy lost $84 in commissions because he opened the store too soon. Stay logged in, stick to “Participating Offers Only”—the fine print is always microscopic—and take screenshots of everything: your subtotal, your reward confirmation. If something goes sideways, support usually helps if you have proof. Learned that from a DIY rewards contest I entered once.

Tools and Stuff You Don’t Think You Need (But You Do)

My kitchen table? Disaster zone. Receipts, promo flyers, three half-dead phone chargers. If you’re doing physical gifts, you need tape, boxes, and ribbon that doesn’t look like it survived a tornado. PSA: packing peanuts ≠ dry pasta. Don’t ask.

Digitally, you need a spreadsheet (ugh) or, at minimum, a browser extension for rewards. Some brands make you tag every order with a commission ID, so double-check your cart. According to Bluesky at Home, the pros track every campaign by date or you’ll miss payouts and just get “out of policy” emails. And get a portable printer if you don’t want to sprint to the shop for every shipping label. I ignored that advice—regret it every December, right up there with the pasta fiasco.